Dear Cara – or -The Problem of Wiberg

by Christine Kent on July 14, 2014

Dear Cara,

My book, Save Your Hips, does talk about dysplasia, a concept first put forth in 1939 by Gunnar Wiberg. By this time, radiology was well established and the practice of orthopedics focused primarily on bones. Throughout the previous century a deep level of understanding had been centered on imbalances in the soft tissues surrounding the joint as the initial, fundamental pathology in common hip disease.

I believe The Problem of Wiberg (I just coined this phrase) to be the tipping point in changing current understanding of chronic hip disease.

Center Edge Angle of Wiberg

Center Edge Angle of Wiberg

Wiberg saw on AP radiograph that some acetabulae provide less coverage to the femoral head than others. Working with impressive 2D images that were easy to manipulate mathematically, he produced a theory stating that at a certain point in his diagnostic parameter, called the center edge angle of Wiberg (CEA), a hip could be considered dysplastic or not.

The CEA contains a large margin of error, however, because it does not take into account the major musculoskeletal movement that positions the acetabular roof over the femoral head which is, of course, sacral nutation (i.e. lordosis). When we lie supine for a standard AP radiograph, the femoral head moves slightly up and out of its socket. When we stand up, the femoral head moves down and medially. The hip joint follows the sacrum in this movement. Therefore, none of the images Wiberg was working with gave a true representation of how much of the weight-bearing joint was actually covered by the acetabular roof. No doubt he saw some very abnormal joints. But his parameter is largely erroneous because it measures spacial relationships in a non-weight-bearing position. This wouldn’t be a problem if the joint didn’t radically change from supine to standing…but it does! Wiberg and all the diagnosticians after him never really knew from an AP radiograph which hips were going to be covered-enough as the lumbar spine extended with standing. There are other imaging technologies today, but no one has wanted to confront The Problem of Wiberg. Therefore the images are digitally manipulated to give a standard AP view of the pelvis (“anterior pelvic plane”).

Crazy, but true. This is what Save Your Hips is all about.

But what were Wiberg and others through the century seeing in a dysplastic acetabulum? That it is “shallow” and “oval-shaped”, instead of more circular (it is actually a spiral, which my daughter, who is also my artist, and I realized at the same moment).

Dysplastic Acetabulum

Normal Acetabulum

The only possible gravitational dynamic capable of creating such an acetabular shape is bearing the center of mass on the front aspect of the joint. One bears the COM in this way by flattening lumbar curvature while weight-bearing. The degree to which the lumbar spine is flattened from its natural, wide-radius curvature, is the same degree the femoral head is moved up and laterally.

It is also true that there is another, far less common, condition where the femoral head has been held slightly out of the joint from birth or early childhood. Thus, we have a true developmental dysplasia, and also an acquired (degenerate) condition. Spinal and/or pelvic obliquity (scoliosis) can also cause the hip joint to twist and elongate.

So how should a thirty or forty-year-old who has new-onset or slowly progressing hip pain with radiologic signs of dysplasia be categorized? You would not be able to determine (other than by history) which hip dysplasia was acquired and which was developmental. The trained eye, however, would be able to tell by subtle differences in the bones themselves. But this distinction is not studied and therefore not mentioned in orthopedic literature. It is all classified as developmental.

Acquired dysplasia causes the anterior aspect of the symmetrical, arched acetabular roof to (1) stretch – as gravity pulls the joint downward, elongating the acetabulum like taffy, and (2) apply bone to what becomes the anterior-superior aspect of the acetabulum in the counternutated position (lumbar curve flattened). This area becomes thickened and protruding as it tries to cover and protect the joint.

Normal Acetabulum

Dysplastic Acetabulum

The process of stretching and bone deposition at the anterior-superior aspect of the joint is probably largely responsible for other popular orthopedic theories, acetabular retroversion and pincer FAI, which describe the same architectural characteristics. This is why I describe in my book how orthopedics creates new diseases out of thin air.

To convolute matters further, the practice of orthopedics believes this dysplastic area to be the weight-bearing roof of the normal acetabulum, due to a 500 year-old misconception of pelvic orientation in the bipedal position.

Orthopedics has used flawed, circular logic to justify the mutilation of millions of hips.

Which kind of dysplasia do you believe you have, Cara?

Wishing you well,
Christine

{ 2 comments }

PAO – A Devastating Operation

by Christine Kent January 6, 2014

Reciting the words spoken by William Harris in 1986, orthopedic surgeons persist in their assertions that “Primary hip osteoarthritis (OA) is extremely rare.”1 These doctors continue to claim that “Up to 90% of young patients ( PAO > THR. Young age is a major risk factor for revision THR, yet untold numbers of post-PAO patients […]

Read the full article →

A Different Perspective on Hip Pain

by Christine Kent December 13, 2013

It is a lot to take in and process that the practice of orthopedic surgery has an inaccurate perspective on the anatomy of the hip. And that the surgeries for femoroacetabular impingement (FAI), developmental dysplasia (DDH), and osteoarthritis of the hip are often based on fallacious imaging studies and erroneous diagnoses. Yet, that is the […]

Read the full article →

Contemporary Hip Surgery – Modern Miracle or High Tech Snake Oil?

by Christine Kent November 30, 2013

About the Author – Christine Kent, RN, is the author of Save Your Hips – Heal Hip Pain Naturally and Avoid Dangerous Orthopedic Surgery (Whole Woman Press, 2013). She is also the author of Saving the Whole Woman, Natural Alternatives to Surgery for Pelvic Organ Prolapse and Urinary Incontinence (2nd ed. Bridgeworks, 2007) as well […]

Read the full article →

The New Kegels – The Effective Way to Manage Pelvic Organ Prolapse

by Christine Kent October 23, 2012

Any woman with long-standing prolapse knows that Kegels do nothing to improve the symptoms of rectocele, cystocele, or uterine prolapse. The only logical reason for Kegels improving symptoms of stress urinary incontinence (losing urine when sneezing, coughing, etc) is that they pull the bladder toward the vagina, thereby increasing the symptoms of cystocele. Women with […]

Read the full article →

A New Model of Core Stability

by Christine Kent October 7, 2012

One of the things that makes human beings unique in nature is the way in which we manage intraabdominal pressure. Intraabdominal pressure is the force that is created through the torso as the lungs fill with air and the respiratory diaphragm moves downward. When a cat sits, it leans the weight of its torso onto […]

Read the full article →

“Just Do Yer Kegels”

by Christine Kent October 1, 2012

Leave it to a man – Arnold Kegel to be precise – to come up with the nonsensical notion that contracting the pelvic floor has anything to do with improving symptoms of prolapse or incontinence. In case you’re just joining in the global Whole Woman paradigm shift, we need to let you in on a […]

Read the full article →

Re-Thinking Deep Squats During The Last Weeks of Pregnancy

by Christine Kent September 26, 2012

In their landmark book, The Labor Progress Handbook, Penny Simkin and Ruth Ancheta describe six steps in the progression of labor1: The cervix moves from a posterior to an anterior position The cervix ripens or softens The cervix effaces The cervix dilates The fetal head rotates, flexes, and molds The fetus descends and is born. […]

Read the full article →

Hysterectomy and the Whole Woman® Posture

by Christine Kent September 20, 2012

When we come into the world as newborn baby girls, our spine is completely straight. Our three pelvic organs and their channels: urethra-bladder, vagina-uterus, rectum-sigmoid colon, form long, straight lines through a funnel-shaped torso. Only when we begin to stand, walk and run under the forces of gravity do pronounced arches appear in our lower […]

Read the full article →

Whole Woman Posture and the Horizontal Spine

by Christine Kent September 17, 2012

~ Still Shouting After All These Years ~ From the beginning of Whole Woman, over a decade ago, I realized that challenging the status quo was going to require a tremendous amount of effort. From the start I called for an end to urogynecology – a practice formed in the late 1970s to take advantage […]

Read the full article →